A Journal of Solidarity and Sustainability
Vol. 12, No. 3, March 2016|
Luis T. Gutiérrez, Editor
Book Review of
Overdevelopment, Overpopulation, Overshoot
Edited by Tom Butler
Population Media Center & Population Institute
Goff Books, 2015
Luis T. Gutiérrez
Every problem facing humanity, from poverty to violent conflict over resources, is exacerbated by a ballooning human population – and so is every problem facing nature, including ecosystem loss, species extinctions, and climate chaos. But why is the demographic explosion and its effects ignored by policymakers and the media? Why do important people within the global environmental movement itself avoid the great challenges of the population issue?
Isn’t it time to start talking about the equation that matters most to the future of people and the planet? Overpopulation + Overdevelopment = Overshoot.
In a book as large and dramatic as the topic it covers, Overdevelopment, Overpopulation, Overshoot (OVER) will ignite that conversation around the world.
In an exhibit-format treatment with provocative photos from across the globe, OVER moves beyond insider debates and tired old arguments (yes, population numbers AND consumption both matter). Framed by essays from population experts Eileen Crist and William Ryerson, as well as a forward by human rights activist Musimbi Kanyoro, the heart of OVER is a series of photo essays illuminating the depth of the damage that human numbers and behavior have caused to the Earth—and which threatens humanity’s future.
"Can you think of any problem in any area of human endeavor on any scale, from microscopic to global, whose long-term solution is in any demonstrable way aided, assisted, or advanced by further increases in population, locally, nationally, or globally?" Albert Bartlett (1923-2013)
Population Growth: 7 Billion and Counting
Population growth seems to be a "politically incorrect" theme for many people, including many highly respected leaders in the international sustainable development community. The reason is that population growth is tightly coupled with issues of human sexuality that many people still find difficult to discuss openly. In some cultures, these issues elicit visceral reactions pursuant to upholding ancient family and institutional structures widely considered to be sacrosanct. This book is a significant contribution to fostering awareness about the criticality of demographic realities for sustainable development and the urgent need for all responsible world citizens to face the absurdity of infinite population in a finite world.
The contents are listed on the right-hand side of this page. The foreword by Musimbi Kanyoro poses the fundamental question: "Can we say, with an honest heart, that the suffering of the earth and millions of her children is not linked to the exponential growth in human numbers?" Biblical literalists would say that this is God's plan since the beginning: "Be fruitful and increase in number; fill the earth and subdue it." (Genesis 1:28) They conveniently forget that God also "took the man and put him in the Garden of Eden to work it and take care of it." (Genesis 2:15) Furthermore, God created humankind, male and female, as rational animals capable of taking care of each other and making decisions for the common good.
by Musimbi Kanyoro
LORD MAN: A PARABLE
by Tom Butler
by William Ryerson
Elbow to Elbow
Trashing the Planet
LORD MAN: PARADOX REDUX
by Eileen Crist
The "Lord Man" parable by Tom Butler provides a panoramic view of how men and women gradually replaced the Lord God's plan with a plan made by human hands; a plan that has little to do with responsible caring and much to do with irresponsible abuse of the entire community of creation. The path from the pristine "garden" of the beginning to the polluted planet we now inhabit has been guided by the insatiable desire for more stuff, more power, more honors. It is not insignificant that this path started after the original communion of man and woman was cursed and replaced by male domination and female subordination (cf. Genesis 3:16).
Coupling of Population and Consumption
The introduction by William Ryerson eloquently describes the magnitude of the "overdevelopment, overpopulation, overshoot" challenge, and correctly focuses on population growth as the crucial issue: "How many people can the Earth sustain, at a reasonable standard of living, while leaving room for diversity of life to flourish?" One by one, he shows the logical absurdity of all attempts to avoid facing this fundamental question. Can we reduce consumption? Even if consumption per capita is reduced to subsistence level, we would eventually run out of space to stand, let alone move around and make room for clean water to flow and food to grow. Can we count on technological breakthroughs? Any technology can be used for the common good or against the common good, and the lessons of human history are not reassuring. Use of contraceptives and other artificial methods of family planning? Fertility rates have declined in some population sectors but continue to be high in others for cultural and/or religious reasons, especially among the poor who can least afford demographic imbalances.
The photo essays are spectacular, and convey in a powerful way the magnitude of the ecological crisis. The parable redux for the "Lord Man" path is ecological conversion of the kind that would have saved past civilizations that collapsed when they outgrew their resource base; except that now we need an even more universal conversion in human relations to prevent a global ecological collapse. Is humankind capable of such conversion?
In the afterword, Eileen Crist provides a tentative answer by way of exploring a population-related question, i.e., what would it take to feed a global population of 10 billion or more people? Could it be done without making the planet uninhabitable? Barring "acts of God," she convincingly argues that the reasonable answer is negative, but offers a more attractive alternative: "that by choosing the wisdom of limitations and humility, humanity can reject life on a planet converted into a human food factory and allow for the rewilding of vast expanses of the biosphere's landscapes and seascapes." In other words, limits to growth with freely and voluntarily embraced limits to total throughput of materials, waste, and energy as required for sustainability; which, in turn, would necessarily require limits to both fertility and consumption rates.
This is where "the rubber meets the road." After analyzing all the economic forces that perpetuate high fertility rates, such as the need for cheap labor and more consumers to feed the growth engine, huge cultural forces are identified as the most pervasive and difficult to overcome. The most powerful resistance comes from the ancient mindset of male domination and female subordination, further exacerbated by religious patriarchy: "the population question is indeed pressing in countries where patriarchic, polygamous, fundamentalist, and military cultures are keeping women handcuffed and thus adding roadblocks to a restored future."
In brief, we need a massive experience of ecological conversion. What kind of policies and actions would contribute to remove these formidable cultural obstacles? At the grassroots level, nonviolent protests and pronouncements by millions of global citizens would be helpful. At the level of local and national governance, as well as international collaboration, it is opportune to consider how the vast amount of knowledge encapsulated in the text and photos of this book is reflected in some of the more important current initiatives, such as the United Nations' Sustainable Development Goals, the recent papal encyclical on taking care of our common home, and the recent Paris agreement about managing climate change.
Sustainable Development Goals
It is undeniable that, by reducing the amounts of food that must be produced, the amounts of materials and energy required to meet other basic necessities, and the amounts of waste and pollution thereby generated, mitigation of population growth rates would be helpful for sustainable development. However, the Sustainable Development Goals do not explicitly mention the need for population stabilization, let alone reduction by any ethical and culturally acceptable means. Goal 5, "achieve gender equality and empower all women and girls", comes close in that it recognizes the human rights of girls and women and the importance of family planning; but there is no explicit recognition that infinite population in a finite planet is a mathematical impossibility.
Recent Encyclical on the Care of Our Common Home
This encyclical is a comprehensive and very appealing discourse on the ecological crisis, and "shows the urgent need for us to move forward in a bold cultural revolution." (Laudato Si', #114). It recognizes that "attention needs to be paid to imbalances in population density" but only after stating that "demographic growth is fully compatible with an integral and shared development" (idem, #50). Also,
"valuing one's own body in its femininity or masculinity is necessary" so that we can "joyfully accept the specific gifts of another man or woman, the work of God the Creator, and find mutual enrichment" (idem, #155). However, the encyclical evades facing practical issues of human fertility and responsible parenthood, and fails to encourage couples to voluntarily (and by mutual consent) limit the number of pregnancies, even if only by natural methods.
Paris Climate Agreement
The COP21 Paris Climate Agreement is good news that made front page in many newspapers worldwide, and should help in the process of penetrating the global collective unconscious.
But anthropogenic climate impacts, like all environmental impacts, are the product of population and consumption for any given set of technologies; and no mention is made of human population and the undeniable fact that anthropogenic climate change would be a nonissue if we had, say, 2 billion people living on the planet instead of 7 billion. Even if the funds requested by developing countries (100 billion dollars) are provided, it is not clear how much will trickle down for real climate mitigation (disaster prevention and remediation) and climate adaptation projects after the governments and elites get their cut. Parsing the "shalls" and "shoulds" in the agreement shows that all the binding "shalls" apply to bureaucratic actions, and all the really physical TBDs are "shoulds." Another good exercise in the "art of the possible," but the demographic dimension of the issue continues to be conveniently ignored.
Overdevelopment, Overpopulation, Overshoot
Given that issues of human sexuality and population growth are crucial for sustainable human development, it would be sensible to engage in all manner of dialogue about these matters, and analyze them from every conceivable perspective, to seek ways of family and population planning that are compliant with human rights, culturally acceptable, and ecologically sound. This is easier said than done, but resigning ourselves to the fact that the subject is taboo, and avoiding it, will not make demographic or ecological issues go away. The textual and photographic essays of this book constitute a shining example of how to bring them up in a compelling way that is also fully respectful of cultural sensitivities. Copies of this book should be made available to all responsible stakeholders, and it is good to know that there is already an initiative to this effect
The following are links to selected resources on human ecology and population growth:
- Human Ecology - Basic Concepts for Sustainable Development, Gerald G. Marten, Earthscan Publications, November 2001
- Integral Ecology - Uniting Multiple Perspectives on the Natural World, Sean Esbjorn-Hargens and Michael E. Zimmerman, Integral Books, 2009
- Natural Family Planning: The Complete Approach, John and Sheila Kippley, Natural Family Planning International, February 2010
- Global Demographic Trends and Future Carbon Emissions, Brian C. O'Neill et al., Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Volume 107, Number 41, 12 October 2010
- An End to Population Growth: Why Family Planning Is Key to a Sustainable Future, Robert Engelman, Solutions, Volume 2, Issue 3, April 2011
- Intended and Unintended Pregnancies Worldwide in 2012 and Recent Trends, Gilda Sedgh, Susheela Singh, and Rubina Hussain, Studies in Family Planning, Volume 45, Number 3, September 2014
- World Population Prospects 2015, United Nations, 29 July 2015
- Demographic Components of Future Population Growth: 2015 Revision, United Nations, 29 July 2015
- UN Reviews Development Goals, But Again Ignores Population Growth, Joseph Chamie, Yale Global, 22 September 2015
- Meditations on Man and Woman, Humanity and Nature, Luis Gutierrez, Mother Pelican Journal of Solidarity and Sustainability, January 2016
|Back to Title|
PelicanWeb Home Page
"The biggest challenge of the day is:|
how to bring about a revolution of the heart,
a revolution that has to start with each one of us."
Dorothy Day (1898-1980)
|Subscribe to the|
Mother Pelican Journal
via the Solidarity-Sustainability Group
Enter your email address: