Mother Pelican
A Journal of Solidarity and Sustainability

Vol. 8, No. 8, August 2012
Luis T. Gutiérrez, Editor
Home Page


Beyond Growth and Rio+20: Steady State or Degrowth?

Source: ATTAC

Rio+20 is come and gone. The rich keep getting richer, the poor keep getting poorer, and the planet keeps getting warmer, but human life goes on with ever increasing frenzy. As Tom Atlee has insightfully observed, things seem to be getting "better and better, and worse and worse, faster and faster." Recent experimental findings pertaining to the Higgs boson and dark matter ('dark energy') filaments might reinforce the expectation that technological advances will come to the rescue of the consumer society, but most people with expertise in sustainable development are cautious about the long-term validity of sustainability "solutions" that try to bypass much needed cultural change toward improved human solidarity with the entire cosmos. Change is the name of the game, but the game is not about getting new widgets and discarding old ones; rather, the game is about change from domination to partnership, from competition to cooperation, from violence to nonviolence. For sustainable development, this is the game that really matters!
Source: Free Digital Photos

Page 1. Book Review of State of the World 2012: Moving Toward Sustainable Prosperity, Erik Assadourian and Michael Renner (Project Directors), Worldwatch Institute, April 2011
Page 2. The Sustainability Revolution: A Societal Paradigm Shift?, by Tom Burns
Page 3. The Future We Need: Reflections on Rio+20, by Michael Renner
Page 4. Three Articles on Growth vs. Steady-State Economics, by Herman Daly and other members of CASSE
Page 5. Complex and Man-made Markets, by Lucio Muñoz
Page 6. The Case for Renaming the Human Race, by Julian Cribb
Page 7. Three Articles on Human Nature & Ecological Justice, by Leonardo Boff
Page 8. Women, Feminism, and the Solidarity Economy, by Julie Matthaei
Page 9. Global Governance of Climate Change, by Tapio Kanninen and Georgios Kostakos

The following supplements have been updated:

Supplement 1: Advances in Sustainable Development (prayer, study, action, news, pubs, tools, data, models)
Supplement 2: Directory of Sustainable Development Resources (library of 1000+ links to online resources)
Supplement 3: Long-Term Strategies for Sustainable Energy (clean energy, mitigation and adaptation strategies)
Supplement 4: Short-Term Strategies for Sustainable Energy (education, taxes, basic income, ISO standards)
Supplement 5: Fostering Gender Equality in Society (gender solidarity and equality, men and women in society)
Supplement 6: Fostering Gender Equality in Religion (liberation from patriarchy, men and women in religion)


The horizontal and vertical scales are not shown in order to avoid giving the impression that this is a prediction. This is a simulated scenario, not a prediction. It portrays dynamic modes of behavior that can be expected during the transition from consumerism to sustainability, as follows:

~ Population, production, and consumption peak, stagnate and/or oscillate with downward trend, and eventually decrease to long-term sustainable levels.
~ The peak in energy availability is followed by a long decline until it settles to the steady-state flow that is allowed by solar (and perhaps other cosmic) sources of energy.
~ The solidarity index is an indicator of social cohesion, which is tightly coupled with the sustainability of resource usage. Solidarity reinforces sustainability and vice versa.

This is not intended to be an "alarmist" scenario. However, it would be wise to take the Precautionary Principle into account when formulation sustainable development policies as we enter the Anthropocene Age. Widespread violence is bound to emerge if demographic and consumption adjustments are to be made involuntarily. Is this "the future we want" for the entire community of nations? NB: The current SDSIM 2.0 is a demo, not a capability.

Book Review of
State of the World 2012:
Moving Toward Sustainable Prosperity

Erik Assadourian and Michael Renner, Project Directors
Worldwatch Institute, April 2012

Luis T. Gutiérrez

This is the 23rd consecutive annual "State of the World" report by the Worldwatch Institute. From cover to cover, the 2012 edition was written in anticipation of Rio+20 Conference on Sustainable Development. This review attempts to summarize the book, and take another look at the results of the conference, now that both are available for analysis.

The Book and the Conference

The book was launched 11 April 2012 in Washington DC. It is a comprehensive assessment of current social and ecological issues, complete with wise albeit "politically incorrect" proposals on how to approach their resolution. In between the very substantive front and back matters, there are seventeen chapters:

Chapter 1. Making the Green Economy Work for Everybody, by Michael Renner
Chapter 2. The Path to Degrowth in Overdeveloped Countries, by Erik Assadourian
Chapter 3. Planning for Inclusive and Sustainable Urban Development, by Eric S. Belsky
Chapter 4. Moving Toward Sustainable Transport, by Michael Replogle and Colin Hughes
Chapter 5. Information and Communications Technologies Creating Livable, Equitable, Sustainable Cities, by Diana Lind
Chapter 6. Measuring U.S. Sustainable Human Development, by Eugenie L. Birch and Amy Lynch
Chapter 7. Reinventing the Corporation, by Allen L. White and Monica Baraldi
Chapter 8. A New Global Architecture for Sustainability Governance, by Maria Ivanova
Chapter 9. Nine Population Strategies to Stop Short of 9 Billion, by Robert Engelman
Chapter 10. From Light Green to Sustainable Buildings, by Kaarin Taipale
Chapter 11. Public Policies on More-Sustainable Consumption, by Helio Mattar
Chapter 12. Mobilizing the Business Community in Brazil and Beyond, by Jorge Abrahão, Paulo Itaracambi, and Henrique Lian
Chapter 13. Growing a Sustainable Future, by Monique Mikhail
Chapter 14. Food Security and Equity in a Climate-Constrained World, by Mia MacDonald
Chapter 15. Biodiversity: Combating the Sixth Mass Extinction, by Bo Normander
Chapter 16. Ecosystem Services for Sustainable Prosperity, by Ida Kubiszewski and Robert Costanza
Chapter 17. Getting Local Government Right, by Joseph Foti

Fittingly, the keynote address at the launching was given by Severn Cullis-Suzuki, now 32 and a mother but having lost nothing of the charisma that led her to become "the girl that silenced the world for five minutes" at the 1992 Earth Summit. The moral urgency of her appeal for ecological sanity continues to resound through deaf ears around the world today, but is now more relevant than ever as population growth, resource depletion, and environmental degradation combine to threaten the viability of human civilization on a global scale. She returned to Rio for the 2012 Earth Summit, and her address to the Green Cross event is worth listening to.

Growth, Stagnation, and Degrowth

Chapters 1 and 2 of the book are pivotal. Chapter 1 provides a clear statement of the problem and identifies the necessary conditions for a global solution, including degrowth. Chapter 2 is about the dynamics of degrowth and shows that these conditions, while indeed necessary, are not sufficient to sustain a consumerist, resource-wasteful economy in a crowded planet.

This is the problem: "Humanity is confronting a severe and complex crisis. Mounting ecosystem stress and resource pressures are accompanied by growing socio-economic problems. The global economy is struggling to get out of a severe recession that was triggered by the implosion of highly speculative financial instruments but more broadly is the result of bursting economic bubbles and unsustainable consumer credit. The economic crisis is sharpening social inequities in the form of insecure employment and growing rich-poor gaps within and among countries."

After reviewing in some detail the causes for the crisis, it is duly noted that the transition from consumerism to sustainability is primarily a social issue and only secondarily a technological one. This had already been noted in the 2010 State of the World report, but is now more forcefully reiterated. The transition will require a radical cultural shift from domination to solidarity, from competition to cooperation, from materialistic development to human development priorities. In a culture of sustainable development, it is no longer acceptable to attain economic development at the expense of nature; but sustainability at the expense of unjust inequality and extreme poverty (with the consequent human underdevelopment) is not an acceptable proposition either. And yet, one or both of these unacceptable states persist throughout the world. Graphically:

SOW2012Chapter1Figure1x.jpg SOW2012Chapter1Figure2x.jpg
Source: State of the World 2012, Worldwatch Institute, Chapter 1, Figures 1 and 2

Rather, a green economy must be a solidarity economy. In other words, "the aspiration is for 'sustainable prosperity' for all - the result of a process of sustainable development that allows all human beings to live with their basic needs met, with their dignity acknowledged, and with abundant opportunity to pursue lives of satisfaction and happiness, all without risk of denying others in the present and the future the ability to do the same." This concept of sustainable prosperity might be a bit utopian, but it is the right goal to pursue, and a number of policy suggestions are offered to facilitate progress in the right direction. However, to keep moving forward, "a new global solidarity for sustainability must take root, ensuring that no one - no country, no community, no individual - is left behind."

Chapter 1 ends as follows: "From growing the economy at all costs, the central focus instead becomes an economy that permits ecological restoration and enables human well-being without materialism." Chapter 2 is about degrowth, specifically with regard to overdeveloped countries: "Degrowth is the intentional redirection of economies away from the perpetual pursuit of growth. For economies beyond the limits of their ecosystems, this includes a planned and controlled contraction to get back in line with planetary boundaries, with the eventual creation of a steady-state economic system that is in balance with Earth's limits." With a reasonable dosage of social solidarity, hopefully this process can unfold mostly on a voluntary basis. Conversely, it is conceivable that, as ecological factors become limiting, humans will have no choice but to compete less, and cooperate more, in order to prosper by "doing more with less." But is it likely that the pressure of "limits to growth" might actually contribute to more equitable society?

It would be unwise to disregard the human capacity to adapt but, most probably, the transition from growth to degrowth will come to pass neither quickly nor smoothly. Growth may be followed by stagnation during a period of time that may be more or less extended depending on short-term economic adjustments and technological fixes. Such adjustments and fixes may induce oscillations (short-term "recoveries" and "recessions") but will not make perpetual growth possible. In the long-term, barring miraculous breakthroughs in the commercialization of as yet poorly understood natural resources such as 'dark energy', and even more improbable advances in social relations, the book is right on target, especially as it pertains to "overdeveloped" countries: a sustainable future includes degrowth in terms of both human demographics and the consumption of goods and services. This is the long-term "prediction" at the end of chapter 2:

"In the end, whether societal leaders accept it or not, the natural limits of the Earth - brought into view by increasing numbers of a population of 7 billion striving to live as consumers - will shatter the myth of continued growth, most likely due to dramatic changes to the planet's systems. Thus degrowth is part of humanity's future. Will people pursue this agenda proactively? Or will earth and its limits drive the contraction of the global economy"?

Source: Dave Reede, CORBIS
Dimensions of Sustainable Prosperity

Chapters 3 to 8 explore "sustainable prosperity" in more specific contexts such as urban development, the transportation sector, corporate culture, and global governance.

It would be impossible for any book - or, for that matter, any encyclopedia - to cover all possible dimensions of sustainable development, for nothing is unrelated to the process of attaining sustainability. With 59% of the global population projected to be living in cities by 2030, urban development is certainly a key dimension. Megacities are energy inefficient, inflate transportation and environmental costs, and isolate people from nature, among other things. In fact, many experience loneliness in cities even though they are surrounded by millions of people, as everyone is too busy running around, or hurrying to catch the next train, or trying to absorb the incessant bombardment of artificial stimuli, to pay attention to anyone else. It would be so much better to have networks of smaller cities surrounded by farms and green areas.

Transportation costs continue to rise under the current system of "unmanaged motorization." The American addiction to cars (and SUVs, and trucks) is now spreading worldwide and is both a major component of energy consumption and a major source of air pollution as well as a useful indicator of income inequality and middle-class emergence. Newly built roads become congested in short order as the number of registered motor vehicles increases even faster than the number of drivers. Information and communications technologies, which could be used in so may positive ways (such as teleconferencing pursuant to reduced traveling) are instead used to capacity for trivial chatting and every conceivable kind of useless traffic, a significant percentage being pornography, while people struggle to remain sane in the midst of a frenzied lifestyle.

Chapter 7, on "reinventing the corporation," is outstanding. It identifies the (mostly colonial) roots of modern corporations, describes the emergence of transnationalism and globalization, the lack of "intergenerational responsibility, environmental stewardship, and social justice" priorities in corporate culture, and the "proliferation of exotic and risky derivatives" in conjunction with financial manipulations devoid of any useful purpose while contributing to make the rich richer, the poor poorer, and the planet warmer. Six "principles of corporate redesign" are proposed for corporations to become tools of sustainable prosperity for all:

"Principle 1. The purpose of the corporation is to harness private interests to serve the public interest.

"Principle 2. Corporations shall accrue fair profits for investors, but not at the expense of the legitimate interests of other stakeholders.

"Principle 3. Corporations shall operate sustainably to meets the needs of the present generation without compromising the ability of future generations to meets their needs.

"Principle 4. Corporations shall distribute their wealth equitably among those who contribute to its creation.

"Principle 5. Corporations shall be governed in a manner that is participatory, transparent, ethical, and accountable.

"Principle 6. Corporations shall not infringe on the right of natural persons to govern themselves, nor infringe on other universal human rights."

Adherence to these principles would be a refreshing improvement over the current corporate culture of short-term profit maximization regardless of long-term consequences, disregard for quality and environmental laws (let alone voluntary standards such as ISO-9000 and ISO-14000), firing people who are not willing to lie to auditors, lobbying to evade financial speculation taxes and ecology taxes, and instead contributing huge sums to political campaigns, among other things. The chapter on corporate redesign is followed by a chapter on global sustainability governance. This chapter is basically a history of UN Environmental Programme (UNEP) initiatives, but no new proposals of principles or practices are offered. The principle of subsidiarity, which would be instrumental for any viable form of global governance, could have been mentioned.

Source: Wikipedia
Policy Tools for Sustainable Prosperity

Chapters 9 to 17 suggest a number of policy tools to support sustainable prosperity. The most important issue is how to help couples behave in a sexually responsible manner and make sensible reproductive decisions. In this regard, fostering gender equality is the most effective path toward the socially responsible regulation of births; and no other method will sustainably work for the common good as long as gender inequality persists. Several other policy issues of practical significance are discussed in these chapters, such as the need for "green" building construction, improving business practices, enhancing food security, conserving biodiversity, managing ecosystem services, and making local governance more participative and more effective. But nothing may work if the current projection of population growth to 9 billion people by 2050 turns out to be accurate.

It is well known that having sex is the consolation of the poor. This, together with the patriarchal culture of women's domination by men, is the root cause of soaring human population. It is no accident that fertility rates decrease as the standard of living improves and the fundamental equality of men and women is recognized. Indeed, the right to life is sacred. But sanctimonious condemnations of abortion and contraception do little to improve the situation, especially when they fail to concurrently denounce the relegation of women to second class citizenship in both society and religion. In chapter 2, it is duly noted that "80% of the people in the world identify themselves as religious," so religion has a huge influence on human behavior and social ethics.

However, as long as religious institutions persist in disguising pre-biblical patriarchal misogyny as God's divine plan, it is legitimate to suspect that organized religion is, at least to some extent, an obstacle to sustainable development in general, and integral human development in particular. The responsible transmission of human life, and the dignity of the human body, undoubtedly point to abstinence as the most virtuous and effective method to regulate fertility rate; but as long as we live in a religiously sanctioned patriarchal culture where men go around getting women pregnant, and then disappearing to avoid responsibility, it is understandable that most people keep turning around, and walking away with fingers in their ears, in response to religious moralizations.

More generally in the secular arena, it seems like "humanity has been acting as if fresh resources were always waiting to be discovered, as if ecological systems were irrelevant to human existence, as if an Earth 2.0 were waiting in the wings in case we finally succeed in trashing this planet" (Chapter 1). This is an apt analogy to the software development process, where it is often taken for granted that Version 1.0 is "throw-away software" to be discarded as soon as Version 2.0 becomes available with all "fixes" done. Actually, what generally happens is that 2.0 is
Source: TITOM
a complete rewrite of 1.0 based on a new software architecture that is still evolving and begins to converge only in 3.0 and beyond. To think that we can re-architect the planet, let alone the cosmos, is at best temerary and at worst insane; but it is humanly possible to re-architect human civilization, and hopefully Rio+20 was one more step in the right direction.

Sustainable Prosperity after Rio+20

The much anticipated Rio+20 conference is now history, and there is no shortage of opinions about what went right, or wrong, or somewhere in between. Understandably, UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon has declared that it was a success: “In Rio, we saw the further evolution of an undeniable global movement for change.” Other observers are deeply disappointed at the lack of specific commitments to action, while others try to assess both the positives and negatives of this historical event. Had Walter Cronkite been reporting from Rio, he simply would have ended by saying "that's the way it is." Indeed, politics is "the art of the possible," and politicians will not move a finger to do anything that is politically incorrect. Global citizens (all 7 billion of them, or a significant percentage thereof) must rise to the occassion and demand from politicians a new civilization of solidarity and sustainability. This book is a significant contribution to this process, and is wholeheartedly recommended to all who already know themselves to be global citizens. Who knows, this lucidly written book may even help some climate change deniers and infinite growth economists to reconsider.


"Out of the sighs of one generation are kneaded the hopes of the next." Thus wrote Brazilian poet Joaquim Machado de Assis over a century ago. Granted that Rio+20 failed to deliver a global commitment to sustainable development (or "sustainable prosperity") as understood in this book, despair is not an option. Rather, we must keep muddling through the transition one day at a time, one year at a time, one decade at a time, while always keeping in mind the common good of humanity in the long-term: our common future, the future we need and the future we want, is a new civilization of solidarity with the entire community of creation.


  • The Limits to Growth, by Donella Meadows, Dennis Meadows, and Jorgen Randers, Potomac Associates, 1972; Island Press, 1993; Chelsea Green, 2004.
  • Our Common Future, Report of the UN World Commission on Environment and Development (Brundtland Commission), 1987.
  • Compendium of the Social Doctrine of the Church, Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace, Vatican City, April 2005.
  • Degrowth or Decadence, Ramón Alcoberro, Barcelona Metropolis, Summer 2009.
  • The Bible and Ecology: Rediscovering the Community of Creation, Richard Bauckham, Baylor University Press, 2010.
  • State of the World 2010: Transforming Cultures from Consumerism to Sustainability, Erik Assadourian, Project Director, Worldwatch Institute, February 2010.
  • The Ecological Wealth of Nations, Global Footprint Network, 2010.
  • The Social Economy or Solidarity Economy: An Embryo Tool for a Sustainable Economy, Jordi Garcia Jané, Conference on Economic Degrowth for Ecological Sustainability, Barcelona, 26-29 March 2010.
  • Energy and the Wealth of Nations, Charles A. S. Hall and Kent A. Klitgaard, Springer, 2011.
  • Plato's Revenge: Politics in the Age of Ecology, William Ophuls, The MIT Press, 2011.
  • Ecological Ethics, Patrick Curry, Polity Press, 2011.
  • Holy Misogyny: Why the Sex and Gender Conflicts in the Early Church Still Matter, April D. DeConick, Continuum, 2011.
  • Sustainability: A Comprehensive Foundation, Tom Theis and Jonathan Tomkin (Editors), University of Illinois and CNX, January 2012.
  • Global Environmental Outlook, GEO-5 Report 5th Edition, UNEP, February 2012.
  • The Future We Want, Rio+20 Conference on Sustainable Development, United Nations, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, June 2012.

  • |Back to SUMMARY & OUTLINE|

    Page 1      Page 2      Page 3      Page 4      Page 5      Page 6      Page 7      Page 8      Page 9

    Supplement 1      Supplement 2      Supplement 3      Supplement 4      Supplement 5      Supplement 6

    PelicanWeb Home Page

    Bookmark and Share

    "Out of the sighs of one generation
    are kneaded the hopes of the next."

    Joaquim Machado de Assis (Brazil, 1839 – 1908)


    Write to the Editor
    Send email to Subscribe
    Send email to Unsubscribe
    Link to the Google Groups Website
    Link to the PelicanWeb Home Page

    Creative Commons License
    ISSN 2165-9672

    Page 1      



    Subscribe to the
    Mother Pelican Journal
    via the Solidarity-Sustainability Group

    Enter your email address: