rainbow500
The PelicanWeb's Journal of Sustainable Development

Research Digest on Integral Human Development,
Spirituality, Solidarity, Sustainability, Democracy, Technology, Nonviolence

Vol. 5, No. 10, October 2009
Luis T. Gutierrez, Editor

Home Page

pclogo

HOME

LOGO

MISSION

RESEARCH

LINKS

NEWS

TOOLS

LETTERS

DOWNLOADS

ARCHIVE

CALL FOR PAPERS

FREE SUBSCRIPTION


SELECTED
EDUCATION
RESOURCES
FOR
SUSTAINABLE
DEVELOPMENT
(click on the
images for
more info)


earthcharterlogo
EARTH
CHARTER


earthcharteresd
EARTH
CHARTER
ESD


unmillennium
MILLENNIUM
DEVELOPMENT
GOALS


bookshelveszins
MAP OF
HUMAN
KNOWLEDGE


internetarchive
INTERNET ARCHIVE


wikipedialogo
WIKIPEDIA


unitednationslogo
UNITED NATIONS


unescoesd
UNESCO ESD


unescoesdgoodpractices
UNESCO ESD
GOOD PRACTICES


unu-esd1
unu-esd2

UNU IAS ESD


geic-esd
UNU GEIC ESD


genderequality
GENDER
EQUALITY


2wings
TWO WINGS
OF A BIRD


sienacollegelogo1
SIENA
VIRTUAL
COLLEGE
List of
Courses

Women in
Christian
Ministry

Women in
Islam


UNICEFLOGO
UNICEF's
PHOTOS OF
THE YEAR


bookcoversed
SOCIO-
ECONOMIC
DEMOCRACY


globeflagdots
GLOBAL
CITIZENSHIP


mediaglobal
MEDIA
GLOBAL


footprint
GLOBAL
FOOTPRINT


WEOLOGO
WORLD
ENV ORG


holybible
BIBLE
GATEWAY


quransearch
QURAN
GATEWAY


svrilogo
SEXUAL
VIOLENCE
RESEARCH


bioversityinternational.jpg
BIODIVERSITY RESEARCH


eilogo
ECOLOGICAL
INTERNET


ftfpp
FACING THE
FUTURE
EDUCATION
RESOURCES


wqsdsu
WEBQUEST
EDUCATION
RESOURCES


ciesincolumbia
EARTH INSTITUTE


esdtoolkit
ESD TOOLKIT


hungergeography
GEOGRAPHY
OF HUNGER


trinityrublev
DIVINE
COMMUNION


wqsdsu
WORLD
COUNCIL OF
CHRISTIAN
CHURCHES


allahesergreen
ISLAM


starofdavid
JUDAISM


bahaifaith
BAHÁ'Í


mimetictheory
GIRARDIAN
BIBLICAL
REFLECTIONS


religioussymbols
RELIGIOUS TOLERANCE


bccaiefesd
BCCA IEF ESD


iisdesd
IISD ESD


gdaeesd
GDAE ESD


intutelogo
INTUTE


unescowwcesd
WCESD
APRIL 2009


undphdr0708
UNDP
HUMAN DEVELOPMENT


undphdr09
UNDP
HDR 2009


worldbank
WORLD BANK


gcaplogo
GCAP


iserlogo
ISER


ifprilogo
IFPRI


ddologo
DEV ORGS


iicdlogo
IICD


oecddevlogo
OECD


eldislogo
ELDIS


gsdrclogo
GSDRC


PEPNETLOGO
PEP NET


demographicresearch
DEMOGRAPHIC
RESEARCH


govspot
WORLD
GOVERNMENTS


worldbraintrack
WORLD
UNIVERSITIES


globalnonkillinglogo
GLOBAL
NONKILLING


all-newspapers-v.gif
WORLD
NEWSPAPERS


planet2025
PLANET 2025


shapingtomorrow
SHAPING
TOMORROW


wfslogosmall
WORLD
FUTURES


littleearthshow
LITTLE EARTH SHOW


UNEP-P4P
PAINT
FOR THE
PLANET


humanbutterflyucs
UNION OF
CONCERNED
SCIENTISTS


globeline
NEW
CIVILIZATION
NETWORK


damiettalogo
DAMIETTA
PEACE
INITIATIVE


sdilogo
SLUM DWELLERS
INTERNATIONAL


integralecologyfrog
INTEGRAL
ECOLOGY
CENTER


micah-challenge
MICAH CHALLENGE


grist10years
GRIST MAGAZINE


ipprlogo2008
PUBLIC POLICY RESEARCH


lsflogo
LEARNING FOR A SUSTAINABLE LIVING


planet-green-logo
PLANET GREEN


globalgovernance
GLOBAL
GOVERNANCE


LSELOGO
LONDON SCHOOL OF ECONOMICS


integralinstitutelogo
INTEGRAL
INSTITUTE


developmentcrossing
DEVELOPMENT
CROSSING


WDLAPRIL2009
WORLD DIGITAL LIBRARY


oxford-ophi
OXFORD
OPHI


uspesdbanner
USP ESD


marysouthardart
LANGUAGE
OF THE HEART


csjthumb
MINISTRY
OF THE ARTS


Education for Sustainable Development - Part 7

SUMMARY

This issue has four pages. A summary of the contents is as follows:

Page 1 is the seventh of the current series of research reports on "Education for Sustainable Development" (ESD). Page 1 has nine sections plus updated announcements, key links, and recent news.

  • Section 1 - brief progress report on the ESD research project.
  • The collapse in participation for V1.7 is an indication of "survey fatigue." Therefore, there is a hiatus on posting additional surveys while V2.0 is in preparation. It is anticipated that V2.0 will be available in January 2010. V2.0 will take into account all the feedback gathered from the 2009 surveys but will be a fresh re-start relative to format, content, and analysis methodologies.

  • Section 2 - combined analysis of the 2009 survey versions (V0 to V1.7)
  • The combined analysis of the 1004 responses received for the 2009 survey versions (V0 to V1.7) is underway. This section presents descriptive statistics on the averages and distributions of relevance rankings (exactly the same question in all versions). In a 1 to 9 scale, the average is higher than 7 for all the UNESCO ESD themes and all the distributions are unimodal and strongly skewed to the right (high relevance). A critical analysis of the numerical results is included in order to provide insight on their meaning for ESD practices.

  • Section 3 - the phases of integral human development.
  • This section is a survey of three psychological theories (or models) of integral human development. It provides a comparative analysis of the human development models proposed by Carl Jung, Roberto Assagioli, and Abraham Maslow. The three models use different terminology for human development phases but share the same goal: the fullest possible human self realization, which can be attained by balancing the inner journey with self giving to others.

  • Section 4 - the nuptial-family context for integral human development.
  • It is time to overcome all taboos about human sexuality. The most fundamental context for integral human development is the nuptial covenant between men and women (Genesis 2:24). This covenant is a fundamental expression of the divine gift of love, which in turn bears fruit by channeling the divine gift of life (Psalm 127:3). The nuptial covenant can be heterosexual or homosexual -- what really matters is mutual self giving. Heterosexual couples can have children naturally. Homosexual couples can have children by adoption. The divine gifts of love and life cannot be monopolized by any artificial norm. Families, and extended families, must remain rooted in the nuptial covenant in order to foster integral human development. This is the path towards humanity becoming a human family.

  • Section 5 - the socioeconomic context for integral human development.
  • Beyond the family, there must be a socioeconomic context capable of nurturing integral human development. Children must grow and learn by imitating others in the practice of human solidarity, seeking ways to attain and sustain nonviolence and social justice, and taking good care of the human habitat. Locally, social responsibilities include responsible use of freedom, including freedom of speech. Bombarding children and youngsters with violence and sex is not conducive to integral human development. Likewise, bombarding people with advertising pursuant to consumerism and instant gratification is not conducive to integral human development. But there is an emerging need to understand the global socioeconomic context for IHD.

  • Section 6 - the socioecological context for integral human development.
  • At this point in human history, overwhelming evidence is emerging about the urgency of reversing environmental deterioration. The two basic strategies are mitigation and adaptation. Mitigation buys time, but mitigation alone may lead to prolonging the agony. Therefore, humanity is confronted with the splendid challenge of adaptation to new ways of life that are healthy for both humans and the human habitat. Hopefully, this process will be supported by adapting technological developments so as to reduce useless junk and enhance quality of life. There are limits to junk, but there are no limits to integral human development.

  • Section 7 - the sociopolitical context for integral human development.
  • As we all know, "politics is the art of the possible." Neither mitigation nor adaptation will be possible unless short term profits cease to be the top priority for businesses and other institutions. Both extreme socialism and extreme capitalism have been shown to fail in reducing the gap between the very rich and the very poor. Both have failed in fostering social justice as is required for sustainable peace. It follows that institutions of governance must undergo a reformation pursuant to mitigation of power struggles and adaptation to civilized resolution of local, national, and global issues. Fully participatory democracy is surely the way to go, but people must insist on democratic structures that take into account the basic socioeconomic needs required for integral human development.

  • Section 8 - the religious-spiritual context for integral human development.
  • Religion is back! God is back! Actually, God is always present in human history, even if some might prefer to see religions disappear because "God is dead." The influence of religion (and religious institutions) on human and social development is undeniable, and it can have both positive and negative impacts on integral human development. Authentic religious devotion can lead to sacrificial self giving. But fanatical (fundamentalist) religious devotion can lead to barbaric violence and terrorism. Reflection on the sacred scriptures from various religious traditions leaves little doubt as to the kind of religious devotion that God desires.

  • Section 9 - some suggestions for prayer, study, and action.
  • The voice of God continues to resound in the events of human history. At times, it is difficult to discern the divine signal from the noise of ideologies and strident dogmatizations manufactured by human hands. The tripod of honest prayer, continuous study of scriptures and traditions, and individual or group actions and initiatives, is both necessary and sufficient to forge ahead in keeping what is good and letting go of what is bad.

    Page 2 is an invited paper entitled Ecohumanism as a Developmental Crossing, by Leslaw Michnowski, Professor of Management, Saint Cross University, Kielce, Poland, on the use of information technology to coordinate the management of global issues and crisis situations.

    Page 3 is an invited paper entitled No Fishhooks, by Bruce Bridgeman, Professor of Psychology and Psychobiology at the University of California-Santa Cruz, on the future of oil and the kinds of oil-free technologies that might be needed in the future.

    Page 4 is an invited paper entitled Education Based Only on Reason is Incomplete, by Rowan Williams, Archbishop of Canterbury, on the need for integrating faith and reason in education.

    Page 5 is an invited paper entitled Integral Human Development and Health: Psychosynthesis in Education for Sustainable Development, by Ewa Bialek, Psychosynthesis Institute of Warsaw, on psychosynthesis in education for sustainable development.

    TABLE OF CONTENTS & NAVIGATION LINKS

    PART 7 OF THE SERIES ON
    EDUCATION FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT

    1. Education for Sustainable Development (ESD)
    2. Combined Analysis of ESD Surveys V0 to V1.7
    3. Phases of Integral Human Development (IHD)
    4. The Nuptial-Family Context for IHD
    5. The Socioeconomic Context for IHD
    6. The Socioecological Context for IHD
    7. The Sociopolitical Context for IHD
    8. The Religious-Spiritual Context for IHD
    9. Suggestions for Prayer, Study, and Action

    UN MDGs & 2015 TARGETS
    UN-UNESCO DESD 2005-2014
    UNDP HUMAN DEVELOPMENT REPORT 2009
    ARCHIVE OF ESD SURVEY FORMS & REPORTS

    OTHER ITEMS

    Sign of the Times
    Unity in Diversity
    Divinity & Humanity
    Solidarity & Subsidiarity
    Sustainable Development
    Sustainable Democracy
    Human Development
    Violence & Nonviolence
    Indicators & Trends
    Children & Youth
    Technology Corner
    Announcements
    Recent News
    Call for Papers
    Free Subscription

    INVITED ARTICLES

    Ecohumanism as a Developmental Crossing, by Leslaw Michnowski (Poland)
    No Fishhooks, by Bruce Bridgeman (USA)
    Education Based Only on Reason is Incomplete, by Rowan Williams (UK)
    Psychosynthesis & Integral Human Development, by Ewa Bialek (Poland)


    1. Education for Sustainable Development

    The collapse in participation for V1.7 is an indication of "survey fatigue." Therefore, there is a hiatus on posting additional surveys while V2.0 is in preparation. It is anticipated that V2.0 will be available in January 2010. V2.0 will take into account all the feedback gathered from the 2009 surveys but will be a fresh re-start relative to format, content, and analysis methodologies.

    Figure 1 shows the number of participants for each version of the test survey, 0 to 1.7. The number of participants grew exponentially from v) to V1.6, then collapsed in V1.7.

    ESDRRV00V17RESPONDENTS
    Figure 1. Number of Respondents for Versions 0 to 1.7

    Exponential growth followed by collapsed is a well known behavior mode for many systems. Exponential growth of socioeconomic systems better be managed before the collapse occurs; else, the collapse may bring about painful social dislocations and much human suffering in addition to further environmental deterioration (see, for example, Collapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed, by Jared Diamond, 2005). This is precisely the situation we face today, as shown here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, and here,

    In the ESD research project, it is a matter of allowing time for "survey fatigue" to subside. A combined analysis of all responses to versions 0 to 1.7 is underway (next section). Version 2.0 is in preparation, and the current plan is to release it in conjunction with the January 2010 issue.


    2. Combined Analysis of Surveys V0 to V1.7

    The combined analysis of the 1004 responses received for the 2009 survey versions (V0 to V1.7) is underway. This section presents descriptive statistics on the averages and distributions of relevance rankings (exactly the same question in all versions). In a 1 to 9 scale, the average is higher than 7 for all the UNESCO ESD themes, and all the distributions are unimodal and strongly skewed to the right (high relevance). A critical analysis of the numerical results is included in order to provide insight on their meaning for ESD practices.

    Figure 2 displays the average relevance ranking for each UNESCO ESD theme. These are the relevance ranking averages for the 1004 responses to sections V0 to V1.7. In previous issues it has been shown that the averages calculated from the responses to each version are stable and in the same range. Strictly speaking, the V0 to V1.7 samples are not independent (some responders did two or more versions), but the consistency from version sample to version sample and the total sample for all versions, while not statistically significant, is strong indication that there is a wide consensus supporting the UNESCO ESD themes.

    ESDRRV00V17AVERAGES
    Figure 2. Average Relevance Rankings for V0 to V1.7 (N=1004)

    The UNESCO ESD web site has recently been revised, but the definitions of the eight themes remain essentially unchanged. The order in which the themes are listed has changed, but we keep the same ordering for themes 1 to 8 in order to avoid confusion. The definitions for the eight themes are now located in the following web pages:

    Figure 3 shows the average relevance rankings by ESD theme for the 1004 responders in Pareto order, i.e., highest to lowest:

    ESDRRV00V17PARETO
    Figure 3. Average Relevance Rankings for V0 to V1.7 in Descending Order (N=1004)

    Environmental stewardship (T3), peace and human security (T6), and sustainable consumption (T8) get the highest relevance rankings, followed by health promotion (T2) and gender equality (T1). Cultural diversity (T5), sustainable urbanization (T7), and rural development (T4) get the lowest average rankings albeit still over 7 in the 1 to 9 relevance scale. To check that the distributions of rankings are uni-modal, the number of responses for each rank (1 to 9) were counted, and the results are shown in Figure 4. Clearly, the distributions are uni-modal and strongly skewed to the right, i.e., the higher relevance rankings.

    ESDRRV00V17DISTRIBUTIONS
    Figure 4. Distributions of Relevance Rankings for V0 to V1.7 (N=1004)

    Critical Analysis of Figures 2, 3, and 4

    Irrespective of the inferential significance of these numbers, due diligence requires the realities underneath the numerical calculations be examined. A "sanity check" of these results can be summarized as follows:

    • Regarding Figure 2, there can be no doubt that the high rankings for all the UNESCO ESD themes are consistent with the full range of knowledge available on sustainable development, including the data of experience. However, it should be noted that the eight themes, and both the theoretical and experiential knowledge about them, is of the observable kind that is amenable to conscious perception. The numbers may also be a mirror of the collective unconscious, but it does not necessarily follow that the collective unconscious is intrinsically ethical, let alone unchangeable.
    • Consider Figure 3. Given the choice of attaining peace and human security (T6) versus attaining a pristine environment (T3), it would seem that T6 is ethically more critical than T3. Likewise, given the choice of attaining gender equality (T1) versus attaining a pristine environment (T3) and/or sustainable consumption (T8), it would seem that T1 is ethically more important than any of the others. In fact, gender equality (T1) is arguably a prerequisite for both peace and human security (T6) and health promotion (T2); so, from an ethical standpoint, it should be the highest priority. Needless to say, these distinctions imply value judgments which are both difficult and unavoidable. These value judgments go to the heart of the matter, but eliciting them and having a civilized dialogue about them requires a degree of human maturity (i.e., integrated human development) that is hard to find.
    • The distributions plotted in Figure 4 again show an overwhelming consensus among the 1004 respondents: each of the eight UNESCO ESD themes is highly relevant, and the few low rankings probably reflect outliers resulting from responder mistakes and/or responder polarization toward having no faith in humankind. Such polarization is often induced by the history of humanity being full of events driven by violence. But even though all humans have a propensity to violence and other forms of social misbehavior, no human being is destined to act violently and/or socially misbehave. Human nature may be weak and broken, but it still encapsulates inner energies for good that await liberation.

    More on these points in the next section.


    3. Phases of Integral Human Development

    This section is a survey of three psychological theories (or models) of integral human development. It provides a comparative analysis of the human development models proposed by Carl Jung, Roberto Assagioli, and Abraham Maslow. The three models use different terminology for human development phases but share the same goal: the fullest possible human self realization, which can be attained by balancing the inner journey with self giving to others.

    In the previous section, it was suggested that a high degree of personal maturity (i.e., integral human development) is required to go beyond what is observable, and therefore amenable to conscious perception, in the complex process of sustainable development. This is critical, since sustainable development is both driven by human beings and attempts to attain the fullest possible development of each person. Granted that such human development can become reality only in the context of relations with others (and this will be the subject of sections 4 to 8) let us consider in some detail what is known about the process that seeks to attain integral human development in each human person.

    Research in human psychology has shown that, when the chips are down, human behavior is mostly driven by energies and motivations that emerge from the unconscious. Table 1 summarizes three models of integral human development that take into account the somatic, conscious, and unconscious dimensions of human nature. There are many other models (or theories) but let's start with just these three, as they seem to be highly relevant to ESD:

    IHDPHASES
    Table 1. Phases of Integral Human Development

    Table 2 provides further albeit concise elaboration for each model. The phases are not strictly sequential for any of the models. Rather, they are recursive and life-long.

    The Psychoanalysis Model of Carl Jung

    Carl Jung (Switzerland, 1875-1961) postulates five phases or levels of maturity: awareness of the persona, awareness of the ego, awareness of the shadow, awareness of the anima (the feminine element in men) or animus (the masculine element in women), and self-individuation. The persona is the "mask" that a person wears in front of others, so that they see what the person want others to see. The ego is the conscious self, or what the person consciously knows h**self to be. The shadow resides in the outer layer of the unconscious and contains unwanted feelings and motivations that have been repressed but nevertheless influence the person's behavior, often in undesirable ways (e.g., Romans 7:19).

    According to Jung, the recognition and integration of the shadow is the "apprentice-piece of becoming whole." The anima (in men) and the animus (in women) abide in the next inner layer of the unconscious and are decisive in the person being able to attain a health and well balanced personality (the reader may want to revisit Section 3 of the September 2009 issue). According to Jung, being in relation with and integrating the anima or animus is the "master-piece of becoming whole." Self-individuation is reached (usually during the second half of life) with "the integration of the unconscious into consciousness," when the person becomes what he or she is, h** own self, fully liberated from the false pretensions of the persona and the manipulation of the unconscious forces. Such a person is really free to become what he or she really is, for h**self and for others.

    From the perspective of integral human development, Jung's greatest insight is that there is woman in man and there is man in woman. At least for those who believe that there is a Communion of Persons in one God, and that there is both masculinity and femininity (plus much more) in God, now the stories of creation make more sense: "So God created man in his own image, in the image of God he created him; male and female he created them." Genesis 1:27. "The man said, "This is now bone of my bones and flesh of my flesh; she shall be called 'woman,' for she was taken out of man." Genesis 2:23. "This is the written account of Adam's line. When God created man, he made him in the likeness of God. He created them male and female and blessed them. And when they were created, he called them "man"." Genesis 5:1-2.

    References
    The Psychosynthesis Model of Roberto Assagioli

    Roberto Assagioli (Italy, 1888-1974) built a model consisting of four stages of human development (self-knowledge, self-control, self-discovery, and self-reconstruction) and seven levels of consciousness and self-realization, as follows:
    Assagioli's Oval Diagram
    egg-diagram-assagioli
    Source: Wikipedia
    Assagioli's Seven Levels

    1. Lower Unconscious - contains "bad" feelings and traumatic memories.
    2. Middle Unconscious - unconscious but supportive of normal conscious living.
    3. Higher Unconscious - "our higher potentialities which seek to express themselves." (Assagioli)
    4. Consciousness - the psychological capability to adjust to daily events.
    5. Conscious Self - "the direct "reflection" or "projection" of Self." (Assagioli)
    6. Transpersonal (Higher) Self - transcends the Self to include the relational and spiritual realms.
    7. Collective Unconscious - the shared human knowledge and experience accumulated over the ages.
    "Only the development of his inner powers can offset the dangers inherent in man's losing control of the tremendous natural forces at his disposal and becoming the victim of his own achievements." - Roberto Assagioli, Photosynthesis Online

    References
    The Hierarchy of Needs Model of Abraham Maslow

    Abraham Maslow (USA, 1908-1970) created the "hierarchy of human needs" in the 1940s. It is a very well-known model, and very useful. The Jung and Assagioli models are focused on the human psyche, but Maslow's model explicitly takes into account the physiological, safety, emotional, love/belonging, esteem/self-esteem, and self-actualization stages of integral human development. The hierarchy of human needs is usually represented as a pyramid, with the most basic needs (physical, physiological) at the bottom and the self-actualization needs (self-identity, purpose in life) at the top.

    "Maslow's hierarchy of needs is predetermined in order of importance. It is often depicted as a pyramid consisting of five levels: the lowest level is associated with physiological needs, while the uppermost level is associated with self-actualization needs, particularly those related to identity and purpose. The higher needs in this hierarchy only come into focus when the lower needs in the pyramid are met. Once an individual has moved upwards to the next level, needs in the lower level will no longer be prioritized. If a lower set of needs is no longer being met, the individual will temporarily re-prioritize those needs by focusing attention on the unfulfilled needs, but will not permanently regress to the lower level. For instance, a businessman at the esteem level who is diagnosed with cancer will spend a great deal of time concentrating on his health (physiological needs), but will continue to value his work performance (esteem needs) and will likely return to work during periods of remission." Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs, Wikipedia, 2009.

    References

    Table 2. Synopsis of the Jung, Assagioli, and Maslow Models

    Maslow's model is the most useful for thinking about sustainable development as a human-centric process. Those who live in extreme poverty are constrained to remain at the bottom of the pyramid. Who can think about self-actualization when the daily struggle is to meet the basic needs of food and shelter? Assagioli's model is most useful for thinking about human development in the context of sustainable development. His approach to education as the best way to prevent the need for costly and time consuming psychotherapy is, at least to some extent, valid for all children and adults whose minimum basic needs are met or at least partially met. Jung's model is costly and time consuming, but remains the most powerful for integral human development in that it integrates the masculine and feminine polarities of the human person. There is a need to integrate this crucial factor into psychosynthesis in terms of both education and psychotherapy.

    The integration of the masculine and feminine polarities in each person is indispensable for integral human development. Children need to perceive early that human nature is both male and female, not male or female. This is the path to gender equality, and it is the only way to untie the gordian knot that suffocates education for sustainable development and the sustainable development process itself.


    4. The Nuptial-Family Context for IHD

    It is time to overcome all taboos about human sexuality. The most fundamental context for integral human development is the nuptial covenant between men and women (Genesis 2:24). This covenant is a fundamental expression of the divine gift of love, which in turn bears fruit by channeling the divine gift of life (Psalm 127:3). The nuptial covenant can be heterosexual or homosexual -- what really matters is mutual self giving. Heterosexual couples can have children naturally. Homosexual couples can have children by adoption. The divine gifts of love and life cannot be monopolized by any artificial norm. Families, and extended families, must remain rooted in the nuptial covenant in order to foster integral human development. This is the path towards humanity becoming a human family.

    Each generation of human beings is responsible for conserving, improving, and transmitting the legacy received from previous generations to their children, grandchildren, and future generations. To this end, God has endowed all human beings with two wondrous gifts: the gift of love and the gift of life. Every human being is responsible for treasuring these gifts and using them well, i.e., for the glory of God and the good of humanity. But they are often taken for granted, abused, and manipulated in every conceivable way. Irresponsible misuse of human sexuality is a tragedy that continues to harm humanity from generation to generation. A better understanding and appreciation of human sexuality may be the most critical need of human civilization; and gender equality, coupled with responsible sexual behavior, is a "sign of the times" for the 21st century.

    Human Sexuality

    Sexual differentiation starts soon after conception, and nine months later a baby is born showing (in most cases) a clear genital differentiation: boy or girl. As they grow and become men and women, there are observable differences in various psychosomatic dimensions: chromosomes, dominance of certain hormones, body language, body measurements, dominant ways of thinking. But humans are either male or female only in the genital dimension. In every other psychosomatic dimension they are bisexual, i.e., both male and female, in the sense that there is a male "polarity" in females and a female "polarity" in males. Human nature is both male and female, most probably has been so since the emergence of hominoids in human prehistory, and certainly has been so since the emergence of homo sapiens sapiens at the inception of human history. This is revealed by the most ancient and sacred texts (Genesis 1, 2, 5) and, as discussed in the previous section, has been scientifically confirmed by psychologists and psychiatrists since the early 20th century.

    The sign of the times during the 17th and 18th centuries was to overcome slavery and attain freedom from colonial powers. The sign of the times during the 20th century was to free nations from totalitarian regimes. There is a growing consensus that the sign of the times for the 21st century is overcoming all primitive taboos and artificial aberrations about human sexuality. These include overcoming the so-called phallic syndrome; all manner of gender discrimination in society and religion; and such things as female mutilation, incest, selling of girls as brides, sex trafficking. Another urgent priority is to recognize that homosexuals are as normal as heterosexuals, even though they might not be as numerous. Just as planet Earth is not the center of the universe, neither the male genitals nor the female genitals are the summit of humanity. Just as slavery and racism have been shown to be gross forms of prejudice and injustice, it must be recognized that there is nothing immoral or intrinsically wrong about homosexuality.

    The Nuptial Gift of Love
    For this reason a man will leave his father and mother
    and be united to his wife, and they will become one flesh.

    Genesis 2:24

    The nuptial gift of love is of divine origin and intrinsic to human nature, but sharing it is a human choice. The adjective "nuptial" comes from the Latin nuptialis, or relating to a wedding covenant. A nuptial covenant must be the free choice of two persons, and it must be a life-long commitment. The use of "must" here should not be understood in a moralizing sense. Experience confirms that the choice must be free and enduring if it is to be for the good of both the couple and society. Becoming one flesh is not something that can be done just for instant gratification devoid of responsibility. Among humans, becoming one flesh is a sacred act and one that is primarily an experience mutual self-giving and mutual submission rather than selfish unilateral pleasure or domination. Else, it is an animal act and one that dehumanizes and makes the experience incompatible with integral human development. For integral human development happens in self-giving and fidelity to others, not in ephemeral acts of self-gratification. In this regard, it is noteworthy that human beings are the only ones that can have sexual relations face to face. Becoming one flesh, and doing so face to face, implies a responsible act of mutual and stable commitment to each other. In this day and age, when the gift of love has been trivialized and even reduced to a commercial product, it is crucial for people to recognize that "casual sex" is bad for human health and has nefarious social effects that are readily observable. For more on the nuptial gift of love, specifically as it pertains to sustainable development, the reader may want to see the May 2008 to August 2008 issues of this journal.

    The Nuptial Gift of Life
    Behold, children are a gift of the Lord,
    the fruit of the womb is a reward.

    Psalm 127:3

    The nuptial gift of life is also of divine origin and intrinsic to human nature, and sharing it is also a human choice that husband and wife make face to face, assuming responsibility for the new life they might pro-create. Again, the purpose of this journal is not to indulge in abstract moralizations but to examine everything in light of what is good or bad for sustainable development and, specifically, integral human development. Heterosexual couples can have children naturally. Both heterosexual and homosexual couples can have children by adoption. Human life starts at conception but must be nurtured and developed at each point during the life of each human person. Children need parents who assume responsibility for their growth, education, and wellbeing. Adults need friends or mentors to assist them in the process of life-long education, and to help them in the process of discerning their vocation so that in due time they can become, in Maslow's words, "what they were born to be." Children and young people can "become what they are," and in due time can assume responsibility for the wellbeing of future generations, if taking good care of them replaces consumerism as the top priority of those of us who are now in the second and third phases of life. This is what being "pro-life" is all about. Being "pro-life" is about recognizing that aborting a baby is a tragedy; that each human life that is cut short by wars and terrorism is a tragedy; that each case in which a person is prevented to become "what he or she was born to be" is a tragedy. Another tragedy, which is common today, is to put old people aside when they can no longer "compete" with younger people, thereby "aborting" the fruits of their long years of experience and accumulated wisdom. For more on the nuptial gift of life, specifically as it pertains to sustainable development, the reader may want to see the May 2008 to August 2008 issues of this journal.

    Bisexuality, Heterosexuality and Homosexuality
    Bisexuality is not a choice; psychologically, all humans are bisexual.
    Heterosexuality is not a choice; most humans are heterosexual.
    Homosexuality is not a choice: some humans are homosexual.
    Scientists have not yet been able to elucidate how is it that some hormonal and neural processes make most men and women heterosexual and some men and women homosexual. But this is no justification to say that homosexuality is an "objective disorder." For we know that, while all human beings share the same human nature, each human being is unique. Likewise, we know that there is a psychosomatic "continuum" of all sexual chacteristics, just as there is a psychosomatic "continuum" of each and every human characteristic. Each human being is unique along this multidimensional continuum, and no particular combination of human characteristics can claim to be "normative" in any psychosomatic or moral sense. In fact, uniqueness in diversity is what makes each person capable of contributing what only he or she can contribute, thereby enriching humanity and collaborating with God in the ongoing process of creation. Thus the beauty of human "unity in diversity."

    The Nuclear Family

    Healthy family life is rooted in the nuptial gifts of love and life. This applies especially to the nuclear family composed of parents and their children. It is well known that nuclear families are the "cells of society." But there is more. Healthy nuclear families are the "incubators" of integral human development. Children who come from unhealthy nuclear families, or who were abused by their parents, or who were conceived in "casual sex" and then abandoned or neglected in one way or another, generally show deep psychological scars throughout life. Very few of these children "become what they are" and "what they were born to be." A few of these abandoned or neglected children are saved by good adopting parents. Adoption is so much better than abortion!

    The Extended Family

    The so-called "extended family" is another blessing for children. Grandparents, aunts and uncles, cousins, and even distant relatives, form a web of life that contributes to nurturing children both physically and psychologically. Extended families are like "microwave ovens" for integral human development. It is in extended families that children learn early that nobody is self-sufficient, that people need each other. Sometimes the support of extended families can compensate, at least partially, for the lack of a healthy nuclear family. This is often the case in "single-parent" nuclear families. The presence of both "father" and "mother" is very important in the life of children and, ideally, the extended family should be a web of nuclear families. But real life is seldom ideal, and it is time to recover the many blessings of extended families.

    The Human Family

    Human civilization is about building humanity as a family: a family of nations, a globally extended family. In this regard, the teachings of the Baha'i faith are worth studying. The unity of humanity is one of the central teachings of the Bahá'í Faith. Bahá'í teachings state that since all humans have been created in the image of God, God does not make any distinction between people regardless of race or colour. Thus, because all humans have been created equal, they all require equal opportunities and treatment. Thus the Bahá'í religion promotes the unity of humanity, and teaches that people's should have a world-embracing vision, i.e., people should love the whole world rather than just their nation. This teaching, however, does not mean unity with uniformity. The Bahá'í writings specifically advocate the principle of unity in diversity whereby the full rainbow of variations in the human race is valued. The reader may want to know more about Bahá'u'lláh (the 19th century Persian founder of the religion) and his teachings on the unity of humanity, gender equality, unity in diversity, the unity of religion and the unity of God. The unity of humanity mirrors the unity of God; and God is a Family!


    5. The Socioeconomic Context for IHD

    Beyond the family, there must be a socioeconomic context capable of nurturing integral human development. Children must grow and learn by imitating others in the practice of human solidarity, seeking ways to attain and sustain nonviolence and social justice, and taking good care of the human habitat. Locally, social responsibilities include responsible use of freedom, including freedom of speech. Bombarding children and youngsters with violence and sex is not conducive to integral human development. Likewise, bombarding people with advertising pursuant to consumerism and instant gratification is not conducive to integral human development. But there is an emerging need to understand the global socioeconomic context for IHD.

    Each reader is familiar with the local socioeconomic context in their local area. Therefore, this section is focused on the global socioeconomic context for IHD. Doing so may have been irrelevant a few decades ago, but it is highly relevant now given the increasing interconnectivity of nations and institutions throughout the world. There is no such thing as a self-sufficient national economy; globalization has taken care of that, and the current global crisis provides irrefutable evidence that we "are all on the same boat" or, in Kenneth Boulding's famous expression, we all live in a single "spaceship planet." Whether we like it or not, the Baha'i prophecy about the unity of humanity is becoming a reality. But what kind of reality and what kind of unity?

    An excellent public domain resource to study the "state of the world" is the Earth Web Site of the Canadian Global Education Project (GEP). It provides a comprehensive report on the "state of the world" organized in the following sections:

    1. Human Conditions (Social, Demographic, Education, Health, HDI)
    2. Global Ecology (Oceans, Biomes, Climate Change, Biodiversity)
    3. Energy Supply (Oil, Coal, Natural Gas, Consumption, Emissions, Peak Oil)
    4. Food and Soil (Arable Land, Grain Production & Consumption, Soils)
    5. Fresh Water (Water Supply, Water Contamination, Uses of Water)
    6. Development & Debt (GDP, Population, GDP per Capita, Debt Trends)
    7. Wealth & Power (Global Power, Politics, Business, Finance, Wealth Inequities)
    8. Fishing & Aquaculture (Global Fisheries, Aquaculture Production, Fish Stocks)
    9. Toxic Pollution (Toxic Chemicals, Levels in Children, Nuclear Waste)
    10. Weapons & Warfare (Military Spending, Exporters, Uranium Depletion)

    As we all know, it is impossible to separate social, economic, political, ecological, and religious dimensions of dimensions of IHD, let alone the total sustainable development process. But analysis requires decomposition into parts to be subsequently re-integrated for increased understanding. From a purely socioeconomic perspective, let us focus on sections 1, 6, and 7. There can be no doubt that the two most critical factors for SD, ESD, and IHD are the gap between the very rich and the very poor (which keeps increasing both within and between nations) and gender inequities which a few of the most advanced nations are starting to resolve but otherwise persist worldwide. Regarding the rich-poor gap, the following chart is self-explanatory:

    GDPPC-HML19602002
    Figure 5. GDP Per Capita for High, Medium and Low Income Countries
    Source: Global Education Institute (Economic Development)

    Regarding gender equality, a very comprehensive resource is the Gender and Human Development, Human Development Report, United Nations, 1995 (free download). Another excellent resource is the RePEc (Research Papers in Economics) online library. The following paper clearly makes the case for gender equality as a pivotal driver of economic development:

    Abstract: "International organizations have expressed widespread agreement that gender equality is an important social and economic goal. Well-being is a multidimensional measure of material status and encompasses income, health, education, empowerment, relative economic and social status, and security, although precise definitions and emphases on the individual components vary. Since the early 1980s, a number of international agencies have produced analyses of gendered trends in well-being. This paper compares and critically assesses the contribution of some of these studies to understanding the state of gender equality and the causal mechanisms that inhibit or promote such a goal." The Road to Gender Equality: Global Trends and the Way Forward, by Stephanie Seguino, University of Connecticut, 2006.

    The issue of economic inequality is usually characterized in terms of income per capita, but other issues lurk under the surface, notably the issue of gender equality and the severe disparities in the integral human development of men and women. Gender equality is really the sword that can untie the gordian knot of sustainable development. But gender inequalities are the intersection of many different factors which themselves constitute a deeper gordian knot. Keep reading ....

    6. The Socioecological Context for IHD

    At this point in human history, overwhelming evidence is emerging about the urgency of reversing environmental deterioration. The two basic strategies are mitigation and adaptation. Mitigation buys time, but mitigation alone may lead to prolonging the agony. Therefore, humanity is confronted with the splendid challenge of adaptation to new ways of life that are healthy for both humans and the human habitat. Hopefully, this process will be supported by adapting technological developments so as to reduce useless junk and enhance quality of life. There are limits to junk, but there are no limits to integral human development.

    IHD cannot possibly happen without a human habitat, and can happen only to some extent in a deteriorated human habitat. It follows that the socioecological context for IHD includes the full range of environmental issues that must be faced in order to conserve and/or restore the human habitat. It also includes all the human-related negative impacts on the natural environment, as well as all the human-related decisions and actions pursuant to conserving and/or restoring natural resources. This means that the previous section blends into this one; for, as Vandana Shiva has stated so eloquently, "resources flow from the poor to the rich, and pollution flows from the rich to the poor."

    Wikipedia provides a very useful taxonomy of environmental issues, inserted below with some minor corrections and additions:

    SoilSoil conservationSoil erosionSoil contaminationSoil salination
    Water pollutionAcid rainEutrophicationMarine pollutionOcean dumpingOil spillsThermal pollutionUrban runoffWater crisisMarine debrisOcean acidificationShip pollutionThermal pollutionUrban runoffWastewater
    Air pollutionSmogTropospheric ozoneIndoor air qualityVolatile organic compoundParticulate matterSulphur oxide
    ConsumerismConsumer capitalismPlanned obsolescenceOver-consumption
    FishingBlast fishingBottom trawlingCyanide fishingGhost netsIllegal, unreported and unregulated fishingOverfishingShark finningWhaling
    LoggingClearcuttingDeforestationIllegal logging
    MiningAcid mine drainageMountaintop removal miningSlurry impoundments

    It is hoped that this taxonomy of issues/links is useful to the reader for further exploration. Another reason for including it hare is that it provides a "big picture" of the magnitude and complexity of environmental sustainability at the global level. Awareness of this "big picture" of environmental issues, and awareness of individual and institutional responsibilities in resolving these issues, is a "must" for IHD.

    7. The Sociopolitical Context for IHD

    As we all know, "politics is the art of the possible." Neither mitigation nor adaptation will be possible unless short term profits cease to be the top priority for businesses and other institutions. Both extreme socialism and extreme capitalism have been shown to fail in reducing the gap between the very rich and the very poor. Both have failed in fostering social justice as is required for sustainable peace. It follows that institutions of governance must undergo a reformation pursuant to mitigation of power struggles and adaptation to civilized resolution of local, national, and global issues. Fully participatory democracy is surely the way to go, but people must insist on democratic structures that take into account the basic socioeconomic needs required for integral human development.

    The world has been moving toward democracy since early in the 19th century:

    DEMOCRATICNATIONS18002003
    Figure 8. Increase in the Number of Democratic Nations (1800-2003)
    Source: Wikipedia Article on Democracy
    Note: Number of nations 1800-2003 scoring 8 or higher on the Polity IV scale, a widely used measure of democracy. Click on the figure to view a larger image.

    It is to be hoped that this trend toward democracy continues, but democracy is still fragile in some nations:

    DEMOCRACYINDEXMAP2007.png
    Figure 9. World Geography of Democracy as of 2007
    Source: Wikipedia Article on Democracy
    Note: Democracy index according to The Economist, 2007. The palest blue countries get a score above 9.5 out of 10 (with Sweden being the most democratic country at 9.88), while the black countries score below 2 (with North Korea being the least democratic at 1.03). Click on the figure to view a larger image.

    The trend toward democratic governance needs to become a trend toward sustainable democracies; else, there may be a regression to totalitarian or theocratic forms of government in a futile attempt to avoid the challenge of the sustainable development process. There is also the question of democratic global governance. The only conceivable way to attain politically sustainable democracy at all levels (local, national, global) is to have checks and balances (within levels and between levels) in accordance with the principle of subsidiarity (see Wikipedia, Acton, Participative Democracy; see also the July 2005 and December 2005 issues of this journal). Concrete examples can be found in the Tenth Amendment to the United States Constitution and Article 10 of the Constitution of the European Union.

    Subsidiarity blends the socioeconomic context (Section 5) and the socioecological context with the sociopolitical context of IHD. It helps to develop in people the difficult virtue of balancing authority and responsibility. This balancing of authority and responsibility is also required for economically sustainable democracy. In this regard, socioeconomic democracy is proposed as plausible way (when coupled with political subsidiarity) to improve social justice and reverse the trend toward further increase of the rich-poor gap, both within nations and between nations:

    socioeconomicdemocracygeorge.gif SOCIOECONOMIC DEMOCRACY: An Advanced Socioeconomic System, by Robley E. George, defines and describes what is meant by the term Socioeconomic Democracy.

    Socioeconomic Democracy is a model economic system, or more precisely, socioeconomic subsystem, in which there is some form of Universal Guaranteed Personal Income as well as some form of Maximum Allowable Personal Wealth, with both the lower bound on personal material poverty and the upper bound on personal material wealth set and adjusted democratically by all society.

    Table 3. Socioeconomic Democracy by Robley E. George (2002)
    Source: Center for the Study of Democratic Societies
    Note: Click on the book cover to view a larger image and the book overview.

    Hopefully, sections 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7 have provided some integrated insight (or, at least, some suggestions for further research) on the psychosomatically healthy, nuptially rooted, socially nurturing, ecologically sound, and politically feasible ways to foster IHD. The next section attempts to complete the "big picture" by taking into account the "inner picture" of the human person: the universal human desire (sometimes repressed) for communion with God. This desire transcends psychology and all manner of human relations, and is discussed in the next section on the religious-spiritual context for IHD.


    8. The Religious-Spiritual Context for IHD

    Religion is back! God is back! Actually, God is always present in human history, even if some might prefer to see religions disappear because "God is dead." The influence of religion (and religious institutions) on human and social development is undeniable, and it can have both positive and negative impacts on integral human development. Authentic religious devotion can lead to sacrificial self giving. But fanatical (fundamentalist) religious devotion can lead to barbaric violence and terrorism. Reflection on the sacred scriptures from various religious traditions leaves little doubt as to the kind of religious devotion that God desires.

    Some people don't like to discuss politics. Some people don't like to discuss religion. This is probably because both subjects tend to be controversial, and they are controversial because they bring into focus the things that really matter (beyond food, water, shelter, and safety) in the secular and spiritual sides of human life, respectively. The previous section addressed secular political issues. This section deals with religion and religious politics.

    Inasmuch as they are schools of spirituality and help people to undertake the inner journey and enjoy communion with God, religions provide an indispensable service to humanity. The various religious traditions encapsulate huge amounts of wisdom gathered down the ages. This is a treasure that must be conserved, purified, and transmitted to future generations. But while religious institutions are good in conserving and transmitting, they tend to procrastinate in purifying religious traditions from old taboos and old aberrations (such as the propensity to valuate the masculine over the feminine -- the so-called phallic syndrome) that accumulate over time and induce practices such as female genital mutilation, various forms of religious violence, and the exclusion of women from roles of religious authority.

    So the problem is not the need for religion and spirituality. The problem is the lack of due diligence in religious institutions distinguishing between wisdom and garbage, and their propensity to conserve and transmit wisdom and garbage together in order to ensure religious orthodoxy. When sustaining religious orthodoxy is good for the psychosomatic and spiritual wellbeing of people, it makes sense to remain orthodox. But when sustaining doctrinal orthodoxy can be shown to be detrimental for the psychosomatic and/or spiritual wellbeing of people, then it is reasonable to suspect (without passing judgment about the intentions of religious authorities) that such doctrines are fabricated by human hands and need to be purified from human errors that have nothing whatsoever to do with what God desires.

    A case in point is the continued refusal by some Christian churches (2.5 billion people, including the largest one, the Roman Catholic church -- 1.2 billion people) to allow feminine access to roles of religious authority. Given that IHD generally requires both masculine and feminine mentorship, it is self-evident that Roman Catholics are thereby liturgically deprived of a significant resource for IHD. Another case in point is the continued resistance from Islamic quarters to overcome primitive thinking and practices about male supremacy. To keep saying that this is what God desires is ridiculous and smells fishy -- this is not the time to play at being God; this is the time to seek divine guidance and do what is for the glory of God and the common good of humanity.


    9. Suggestions for Prayer, Study, and Action

    PRAYER SUGGESTION:

    The Serenity Prayer
    by Reinhold Niebuhr (1892-1971)

    God, give us grace to accept with serenity
    the things that cannot be changed,
    Courage to change the things
    which should be changed,
    and the Wisdom to distinguish
    the one from the other.

    Living one day at a time,
    Enjoying one moment at a time,
    Accepting hardship as a pathway to peace,
    Taking, as Jesus did,
    This sinful world as it is,
    Not as I would have it,
    Trusting that You will make all things right,
    If I surrender to Your will,
    So that I may be reasonably happy in this life,
    And supremely happy with You forever in the next.

    Amen.

    STUDY SUGGESTION:

    Read a good book that will help you think "outside the box." For example, if you want to learn how religious institutions exclude women from certain ministerial roles, this one is fascinating: The Hidden History of Women's Ordination: Female Clergy in the Medieval West, by Gary Macy, Santa Clara University, Oxford University Press, 2008, 260 pages.

    ACTION SUGGESTION:

    Write a letter to your secular and/or religious leaders, or perhaps to the editor of your local newspaper. Express your concerns. Ask honest questions. Request an answer. Be positive and respectful. Offer volunteer help. You can use a regular letter, or an e-mail, or any other media; but we are all responsible for communicating our concerns and insights to the proper authorities in both secular and religious institutions.


    Archive of ESD Survey Forms & Reports


    The Education for Sustainable Development (ESD) research project is moving forward as a series of surveys to identify the critical issues that sustainable developers must be ready to face. During the year 2009, survey test versions V0 to V1.7 have been posted. The survey is structured around the "key action themes" proposed by UNESCO for the "Decade of Education for Sustainable Development" (2005-2014):

    The survey's design is based on:
    • Paulo Freire's educational model of recursive questions and answers
    • Ken Wilber's integral model of experience, behavior, systems, and cultures
    • René Girard's mimetic theory of scapegoating behavior
    • Note: For a complete description of the design evolution, click here

    The survey of the design is stable. However, the questions still need more work pursuant to an optimal combination of brevity (maximum of 16 questions), neutrality (unbiased questions), and questionnaire coverage of the most critical issues in sustainable development. Thus far the responses have been as follows:

    • As of 24 April 2009, 61 persons had taken the V0 test survey.
    • As of 27 May 2009, 129 persons had taken the V1 test survey.
    • As of 27 June 2009, 263 persons had taken the V1.5 test survey.
    • As of 31 July 2009, 513 persons had taken the V1.6 test survey.
    • As of 29 August 2009, 36 persons had taken the V1.7 test survey.

    Links to the forms, data, and analyses for the initial series of surveys are listed below:

    TEST SURVEY VERSION 0 (40 QUESTIONS) - APRIL 2009

    TEST SURVEY VERSION 1.0/1.1 (40 QUESTIONS) - MAY 2009

    TEST SURVEY VERSION 1.5 (40 QUESTIONS) - JUNE 2009

    TEST SURVEY VERSION 1.6 (16 QUESTIONS) - JULY 2009

    TEST SURVEY VERSION 1.7 (32 QUESTIONS) - AUGUST 2009

    TEST SURVEY VERSION 2.0 - TBD

    Version 2.0 is in preparation. Posting of V2.0 is planned for January 2010.


    |Back to SUMMARY| |Back to OUTLINE|

    |Back to SECTION 1| |Back to SECTION 2| |Back to SECTION 3|
    |Back to SECTION 4| |Back to SECTION 5| |Back to SECTION 6|
    |Back to SECTION 7| |Back to SECTION 8| |Back to SECTION 9|


    | Link to Page 2 |      | Link to Page 3 |      | Link to Page 4 |      | Link to Page 5 |

    |Link to the Home Page|

    Sign of the Times

    Gender Equality

    gendersymbols135
    Source: Wikipedia

    Gender equity is a "sign of the times." Gender inequities are universally rooted in the utter misconception (the so-called "phallic syndrome") that men are superior to women, and lead to incalculable forms of physical and psychological gender violence. It follows, that gender inequities constitute a huge obstacle to human solidarity and sustainable development. It is imperative to overcome, sooner rather than later, gender inequities in both secular and religious institutions, because human development stagnates in the absence of gender balance, and this cannot possibly be what God desires.

    Visualization
    afghangirls
    A Cause for the Century
    Photo by tldagny available under a CCL.


    Unity in Diversity

    Unity in diversity enriches both the individual and the community, and so does diversity in unity. Unity in uniformity enriches neither the individual nor the community, and forced uniformity never leads to unity of hearts. In fact, forced uniformity leads to a fossilization of human relations that eventually corrupts unity and brings about tensions and even violence. For neither individuals nor communities can stay healthy (let alone happy) when confined to any form of straitjacket. Both human development and community development wither when constrained by forced uniformities. It follows that unity in uniformity makes sustainable development impossible. But sustainable development flourishes when unity and diversity enhance each other, thus enabling humanity to forge ahead along the path of peace and justice.

    Visualization
    peoplesworld
    Illustrated Map on
    Peoples of the World


    Announcements

    Conferences 2009

    CLIMATE CHANGE
    The world's climate neutral Scientific Climate Conference, 2-6 November 2009 online. Organized by the Hamburg University of Applied Sciences. For more information, visit the CLIMATE 2009 conference website and contact the conference staff at CLIMATE 2009. Note: the website already includes a listing of climate studies available at the Climate Change Studies Library (CCSL).

    STATE OF THE WORLD CONFERENCE 2009
    November 12-14, 2009, Washington DC. Sponsored by the Integral Institute (Ken Wilber et al). The theme is: "Mobilizing to Save Civilization: A Ten Year Plan to Address Climate Change." From the conference web site: "It is to bring attention to the critical issue of climate change and to catalyze a ten year plan to green our economies that the State of the World Forum is convening a three day conference November 12-14, 2009 in Washington D.C. The 2009 Forum will launch a ten year campaign that will meet in a different world city each year." Current point of contact: DC Hilton Hotel, Washington DC, USA, 1-202-483-3000. Other contacts will be posted as they become available.

    BEHAVIOR, ENERGY &
    CLIMATE CHANGE

    The 2009 BECC Conference is the 3rd annual conference focused on accelerating our transition to an energy-efficient and low carbon economy through an improved understanding and application of social & behavioral mechanisms of change. Sponsored by the American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy (ACEEE). When: November 15-18th, 2009. Where: Washington DC. For more details visit the BECC 2009 Conference web site or contact the BECC 2009 Conference Chair.

    EARTH SYSTEM GOVERNANCE
    "Earth System Governance: People, Places, and the Planet." 2009 Amsterdam Conference on the Human Dimensions of Global Environmental Change. Amsterdam, 2-4 December 2009. Launch event of the Earth System Governance Project, a new ten-year research programme under the auspices of the International Human Dimensions Programme on Global Environmental Change (IHDP). For more information, visit the conference website or contact Frank Biermann.

    PARLIAMENT OF THE
    WORLD'S RELIGIONS

    Parliament of the World's Religions, 3-9 December 2009, Melbourne, Australia. Key topics: Healing the Earth with Care and Concern, Reconciling with Indigenous Peoples, Overcoming Poverty in a Patriarchal World, Securing Food and Water for all People, Building Peace in the Pursuit of Justice, Creating Social Cohesion in Village and City, Sharing Wisdom in the Search for Inner Peace. For more info: PWR2009.

    Conferences 2010

    ROAD TO NUCLEAR ZERO
    AND ARMS CONTROL

    Sponsored by the International School on Disarmament and Research on Conflicts (ISODARCO), Università di Roma "Tor Vergata," Rome, Italy. Location: Andalo (Trento). Dates: 10-17 January 2010. The 2010 ISODARCO Winter School will be devoted to the practical steps to be implemented to arrive to a nuclear-weapon free world, with emphasis on the potential role for arms control. Apply on-line at the ISODARCO web site or download an application form from the same location. Applications should arrive not later than 16 November 2009 and should be addressed to the Director of the School, Prof. Carlo Schaerf

    NEW GREEN ECONOMY
    The National Council for Science and the Environment (NCSE) is pleased to request your participation at the 10th National Conference for Science, Policy and the Environment: The New Green Economy: Aligning Science, Education, Markets and Systems for Sustainability to be held January 20-22, 2010 at the Ronald Reagan Building and International Trade Center in Washington, DC. Please plan to join NCSE in a large interactive conference to develop and advance science-based solutions for the creation of a “green print” to achieve a sustainable, new green economy. See the conference website. Questions? Contact the NCSE Green Economy Conference

    ART & SOCIAL JUSTICE
    Durban University of Technology and Art for Humanity invite you to a three day international conference on Art and Social Justice. Dates: 21 – 24 March 2010. Venue: Durban University of Technology (DUT), Ritson Rd Hotel School, Conference Centre, Durban, South Africa. Point of contact: Art & Social Justice Conference.

    ENERGY TRANSITIONS
    Energy transitions in an interdependent world. Sponsored by the Science & Technology Policy Research Group, University of Sussex. The conference will be held at the University of Sussex, near Brighton, on the 25th and 26th February 2010. Further details including the full conference call and application guidelines are available from the conference web site. Point of contact: Lee Stapleton.

    EVO-ENVIRONMENT
    EvoEnvironment 2, an event of the EvoApplications Conference is devoted to the use of nature inspired methods for environmental issues. Istanbul Technical University, Istanbul, Turkey, 7th - 9th April 2010. Further details including the full conference call and application guidelines are available from the EvoStar 2010 Web Site. Points of contact: Marc Ebner, University of Tuebingen, Germany, and Neil Urquhart, Edinburgh Napier University, UK.

    GLOBAL HEALTH
    The World's Leading Idea Incubator For Global Health Innovation A Conference Presented Annually by Unite For Sight. Saturday, April 17 - Sunday, April 18, 2010. Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut, USA. The Global Health & Innovation Summit convenes more than 2,200 participants from 55 countries. The Summit challenges students, professionals, educators, doctors, scientists, lawyers, universities, corporations, nonprofits, and others, to develop innovative, effective solutions to achieve global goals. Visit the conference web site for registration and contact information.

    APPLIED ENERGY
    International Conference on Applied Energy (ICAE2010). Sponsored by the University of Singapore. Theme: "Energy Solutions for a Sustainable World." 21-23 April 2010, Singapore. Call for papers and other conference information: ICAE 2010 Web Site. Point of contact: ICAE 2010.

    GLOBAL LANDSCAPES
    The interdisciplinary conference “Global Landscapes: Ethics, Entrepreneurship and Organizations in an Era of Global Economic and Financial Crisis” will assemble scholars, educators, graduate and undergraduate students, and community members interested in ethics, entrepreneurship, and organizations. 22-23 April 2010, King’s College, Wilkes-Barre, PA, USA. Visit the Conference Web Site. Point of contact: Conference Chair.

    SELF-DETERMINATION The 4th International Conference on Self-Determination Theory (SDT) will be held at Ghent University (Belgium), May 13-16, 2010. More information about the conference is provided in the SDT Conference Web Site, including guidelines for papers and posters submissions. Point of contact: Maarten Vansteenkiste.

    ENERGY EFFICIENCY
    Conference sponsored by the International Energy Agency (IEA) and the International Energy Program Evaluation Conference (IEPEC). Paris, France, 8-10 June 2010. Theme: "Counting on Energy Efficiency-It's Why Evaluation Matters!" Web sites: IEPEC 2009 and IEPEC-IEA 2010. Email: Cara Lee Mahany Braithwait.

    SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT IN FOOD & AGRICULTURE
    International Symposium: Innovation and Sustainable Development in Food & Agriculture (June 28-July 1, 2010, Montpellier, France). Theme: "Facing the crisis and growing uncertainties, can science and societies reinvent agricultural and food systems to achieve sustainability?" Sponsored by CIRAD. For more information: ISDA 2010 Web Site. Email: ISDA 2010.

    SOCIOLOGY CONGRESS
    International Sociological Association (ISA) World Congress of Sociology, 11-17 July 2010, Gothenburg, Sweden. Session on "Peace, Conflict, and Climate Change" currently scheduled for Wednesday 14 July 2010. See the conference web site for more details or contact the conference chair, Hans Joas, Universität Erfurt, Germany.

    SYSTEM DYNAMICS
    2010 International Conference of the System Dynamics Society, Seoul, Korea, July 25 - 29, 2010. The main theme will be "Beyond the Crisis: Greening Economy, Society and Future," reflecting global concerns about the environment and economic problems. Conference Chair: Man-Hyung Lee, Chungbuk National University. Points of contact: Program Chair or Seoul Conference Team.

    RELIGION: A HUMAN PHENOMENON
    International Association for the History of Religions (IAHR), 15-21 August 2010, Toronto, Canada. Visit the conference website. The conference director is Professor Donald Wiebe.

    ECOLOGICAL ECONOMICS
    ISEE 2010. This is the 11th Biennial Conference of the International Society for Ecological Economics (ISEE). Theme: "Advancing Sustainability in a Time of Crisis." To take place in Oldenburg and Bremen, Germany, 22 - 25 August 2010. For more information visit the conference web site. A presentation containing general information about the conference can be downloaded here. The point of contact is Prof. Bernd Siebenhüner, Oldenburg University.

    Conferences 2011

    STUDY OF THE COMMONS
    The International Association for the Study of the Commons (IASC) has announced its 13th biennial conference. The conference will be hosted by Foundation for Ecological Security (FES). It will take place in Hyderabad, India, 10 - 14th January 2011. To visit the IASCP web site, click here. A PDF file containing general information about the conference can be downloaded here. For more information contact IASC executive director, Jim Robson.

    PEACE CONVOCATION
    The International Ecumenical Peace Convocation (IEPC) will be the Harvest Festival of the Decade to Overcome Violence and at the same time a planting season for fresh initiatives. May 2011, Kingston, Jamaica. Sponsored by the World Council of Churches (WCC). Visit the IEPC web site, which provides points of contact worldwide.

    CFPs

    CALL FOR PAPERS
    SUSTAINABILITY SCIENCE

    Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America (PNAS). PNAS has launched a new section of the journal dedicated to sustainability science, an emerging field of research dealing with the interactions between natural and social systems, and with how those interactions affect the challenge of sustainability: meeting the needs of present and future generations while substantially reducing poverty and conserving the planet’s life support systems. PNAS seeks original research contributions for this new section on both the fundamental character of interactions among humans, their technologies, and the environment, and on the use of such knowledge to advance sustainability goals relevant to water, food, energy, health, habitation, mobility, and ecosystem services. PNAS welcomes outstanding sustainability science papers addressing spatial scales from the global to the local and drawing on a wide range of disciplinary and multidisciplinary approaches. For more information, please contact Josiah Armour.

    CALL FOR PAPERS
    RELIGION & SPIRITUALITY

    This issue of Feminist Review, edited by Lyn Thomas and Avtar Brah, will explore a range of religious and spiritual practices through the lens of gender, and will encompass both theoretical and empirical approaches. We hope to engage with feminism’s long history of critique of the patriarchal nature of world religions such as Christianity, Judaism and Islam, and more recent problematisations of these approaches in light of feminism’s relationship to the Enlightenment and to colonialism. Recent work on the gendering of secularisation theories and on women’s practice of faith and spirituality has complicated and nuanced feminist approaches to religion; this issue will address these questions, while attempting to broaden the debate beyond the binary oppositions and alignments of religion (and most notably Islam) with tradition and ‘backwardness’, and of feminisms with modernity and secularism. Submissions for the issue are welcomed from now until February 28th, 2010. Point of contact: Dr Lyn Thomas.


    INTERNATIONAL ECUMENICAL PEACE CONVOCATION

    WCC2011.jpg

    Kingston, Jamaica, will be the host city for the International Ecumenical Peace Convocation in May 2011. The convocation is sponsored by the World Council of Churches (WCC) and will meet under the theme "Glory to God and peace on earth". It will be the culmination of the WCC's Decade to Overcome Violence (DOV), which has sought to network and bring attention to the peacemaking initiatives of its various member churches. Read the convocation announcement.


    GOOD RESOURCES

    HDR2009
    UNDP
    Human Development
    Report 2009

    Overcoming barriers:
    Human mobility and development
    Scheduled for publication
    October 2009

    UNESCO-OER
    Open Educational Resources: Conversations in Cyberspace
    Edited by Susan D'Antoni and Catriona Savage, UNESCO
    Paris, France
    August 2009

    ccciusreport
    Global Climate Change
    Impacts in the United States

    US Global Change
    Research Program
    Washington DC
    June 2009

    CCC2009
    Climate Change Compendium
    UN Environmental Programme
    September 2009

    COP15LOGOX
    United Nations
    Climate Change Conference

    Copenhagen
    December 7-18, 2009

    earthday2010
    EARTH DAY
    40th Anniversary
    April 2010

    SOWGEP2009
    Earth Presentation:
    A Graphic Look at the
    State of the World

    Policy Innovations online magazine for a fairer globalization



    PelicanWeb
    Call for Papers

    Both subscribers and nonsubscribers are cordially invited to submit a paper to be considered for publication in the PelicanWeb Journal of Sustainable Development as an "invited paper." It should be related to the journal's theme about solidarity, sustainability, and nonviolence as the three pillars of sustainable development. In particular, the current focus is on education for sustainable development. Some suggested themes:

  • Successful initiatives to foster solidarity, sustainability, and nonviolence
  • Gender equality as a positive factor for sustainable development
  • Removal of obstacles for progress toward any or all the UN MDGs
  • Management of technologies for social and environmental justice
  • How to foster human development via spirituality and the inner journey
  • How to foster human and social development via acts of solidarity
  • How to improve systems of governance via checks and balances
  • How to evolve collectively toward a culture of sustainability
  • Invited papers will be published in a separate web page. If you have friends who could submit a good paper, please invite them to do so.

    Please email your papers to the Editor.

    Recent News

    cooltextnews

    Life in the 2010s: moving towards mid-century and beyond

    A year after meltdown: Tough questions, choices

    Chemical pollutants in fish

    The Ethical Responsibility to Reduce Energy Consumption

    Agriculture at a Crossroads

    Face of urban poverty

    The Globalization of agribusiness and developing World Food Systems

    The Globalization of Agribusiness and Developing World Food Systems

    Our Share of Globalization

    ENVIRONMENT: Desert Winds Stir New Hope

    Arctic Thaw Could Cause Massive Flood, Curbing Non-CO2 Pollutants Could Help

    Declining Support for bin Laden and Suicide Bombing

    ENVIRONMENT: Climate Change a Decisive Threat to Development

    Four Challenges in Pittsburgh

    The Future of the Global Recovery

    After September 11th: Change in the Academy?

    The Global Economic Crisis Hampers Human Development

    Indonesia's Aceh to allow stoning for adulterers

    Church lobbies UN on ‘climate justice’

    Stewards of Creation

    Education based only on reason is incomplete

    Financial crisis 'forcing world's poorest children out of classroom'

    World Leaders Pledge to Accelerate Climate Change Action

    Carl Jung and the Holy Grail of the Unconscious

    Earth Overshoot Day 2009

    ENVIRONMENT: Cairo Sinking in Garbage

    What's wrong with UNESCO

    Do Poorer Countries Have Less Capacity for Redistribution?

    Global Initiative to take on gender inequality

    MADAGASCAR: Poverty Forces 2 Million Children into Hard Labour

    G20: Stiglitz and Sen Come In Too Late

    ZAMBIA: Farmers Resort to Human Waste for Fertiliser

    LATIN AMERICA: Desertification – an Invisible Cancer

    AFRICA: Plant Trees To Boost Agricultural Output

    UN Climate Change Summit (Slide Show)

    ENVIRONMENT: Act Now or Lose Forever, Climate Summit Told

    ENERGY: Trees: Out of the Forest and Into the Oven

    SOUTH ASIA: Disunity Hovers over a Region Battling Climate Change

    POPULATION: Where’s Family Planning on Climate Change Radar?

    China Backpedals on Emissions But Still Noncommittal

    Behind the U.N. hoopla, a new agency for women emerges

    Bridging the gender gap

    DESD Quarterly Highlights

    Global capital markets: Entering a new era

    GE Energy launches smart grid Web site

    Climate change damage comes sooner than expected

    Science Report: Climate Change Speeding Toward Irreversible Tipping Points

    Climate Change Science Compendium 2009

    UN: Climate change surpasses worst-case scenarios

    Women's Rights in Developing World Receive New Focus

    Human rights before religion

    Toxic Legacy - Why the Environment is a Life Issue

    Scientists identify “safe operating space for humanity” in seminal Nature study

    Planetary Boundaries

    Climate Change Report

    Road to Copenhagen

    WWF finds tons of new species about to be wiped out by climate change [slideshow]

    Climate protesters hit the streets in Pittsburgh during G20 meeting

    The Overpopulation Hubbub

    The population delusion

    DEVELOPMENT: ‘Gender Is No Distraction in Climate Change Talks’

    A Cause for the Century

    Do CCT Programmes Have a Pro-Poor Spillover Effect?

    GENDER POINT: Lessons from Liberia on Millennium Goals

    New aid agency report challenges prevailing economic orthodoxies

    Getting Back on the Rails: The Private Sector and Development'

    A Future Without Female Genital Mutilation

    Victoria Leading the Way for a Low-Carbon Future

    Pious Words, Puny Deeds: The "International Community" and Mass Atrocities

    HEALTH-ANGOLA: "It's Normal Here That Children Die Young"

    MALAWI: Pre-school Education A Luxury

    ZAMBIA: Malaria Prevention Pays Off

    A bad climate for development

    New breed of energy glutton in the home

    Businesses push for global climate agreement at UN

    World climate business revenue $2 trillion by 2020

    Measuring Gross Domestic Happiness

    Risks & Opportunities of Climate and Environmental Change Explored by Leading International Experts & Executives in New DVD/Web Program for Businesses.

    Global Ethics Corner Explores Sustainability

    Economics of Adaptation to Climate Change

    Poor Nations' Climate Adaptation Could Cost $100 Billion a Year


    "Come now, let us reason together, says the Lord."

    Isaiah 1:18

    GROUP COMMANDS AND WEBSITES

    Write to the Editor
    Send email to Subscribe
    Send email to Unsubscribe
    Link to the Google Groups Website
    Link to the Home Page

    CREATIVE
    COMMONS
    LICENSE

    Creative Commons License

    Page 1      

    FREE SUBSCRIPTION

    [groups_small]

    Subscribe to the
    "PelicanWeb's Journal of
    Integral Human Development"

    via the Solidarity-Sustainability Group

    Enter your email address: